Monday, March 22, 2010

There Were Three of Them

Just last month, there were three of them-all women, all about my age, all white.  Three of them. Not one lone extremist. Three of them, standing in the afternoon thunder shower, across from the  Holocaust Museum in DC, holding signs saying, "Jews Killed Jesus," "God Hates Jews," and "Jews are Going to Hell." One had a sign down by her right side, apparently of lesser importance, depicting a human fetus as the meat in what was captioned, "Obamaburger." Three of them, supporting one another. Three of them who had to travel there, make the signs, and stand on a street corner in a thunderstorm. 

I wanted to walk across the street and ask them what it was in their life experience that led them there-to stand on a street corner and use their first amendment right to spew that sort of hatred, and how their obvious hatred for Jews got all tied up with the dig at Obama about abortion, and what it's like to live, day in, day out, carrying that sort of hate. And how it is that there was no one in their life who stepped up to challenge them, to say, "have you lost your mind?" But, I didn't. Do we ever?

They were women. They looked like me. And there were three of them. Somehow that made it worse.

And, then today, this. Are they related? To each other? To the person who shot Dr. Tiller? Probably only by hatred.

Comments (1)add comment
mark.maisel: ...
Your observation and response to it does you justice, Amy. I've been wondering about hate and willful ignorance all of my life. The best I can tell, including some of my own experience, is that hate can be energizing. It also can easily help establish purpose. This is where the willful ignorance is useful. Folks make up their minds, or allow others to do it for them, they then close their minds to any new information, and before you know it, they will engage in all manner of speech and behavior with the energy of their hate. They do so without regard for the tenets of their professed religious beliefs. For those who claim no religious belief, a comparable mechanism of smugness and certainty will suffice in the same way that religious belief can.

While one may fervently wish to question as you did with those women in DC, it has been my experience that it is futile. Their minds are made up and closed, and their certainty of rightness and your wrongness, should you dare to disagree or question, is beyond question.

I also believe that no society or culture can ever extinguish hatred. Some folks are more predisposed to it and it takes very little to activate it.
1

report abuse
vote down
vote up
June 11, 2009
Votes: +0

Write comment
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy